ACLU Files Lawsuit in Case of Denver Residents Blocked from Bush Event Because of Bumper Sticker (11/21/2005)
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE CONTACT: media@acluorg
DENVER --White House event staffers unlawfully removed two Denver residents
from a town
hall discussion with President Bush because of an
anti-war
bumper sticker on
their car, charged the American
Civil Liberties Union
in a federal lawsuit filed
today.
“The
government should not be in the business of silencing Americans
who are
perceived to be critical of certain policy decisions,”
said
ACLU Senior Staff
Attorney Chris Hansen, who is the lead
counsel in
this case. “The president
should be willing to be
in the same room with
people who might disagree with
him,
especially at a public,
taxpayer-funded town hall.”
Today’s
lawsuit was filed on
behalf of Leslie Weise and
Alex Young, who gained national
attention
after being removed
from a March 21 event with President Bush. The
presidential
visit was open to the public and advertised as a town hall
“conversation” on Social Security reform. But the ACLU lawsuit
charges
that
Weise and Young, who had obtained tickets from
the office of
Representative Bob
Beauprez and had caused no
disruption at the town
hall, were removed from the
event
solely because of their perceived
political views.
After
approaching the security
metal detectors, Weise was
asked to show her
identification, while
Young was allowed in.
The staff at the event then told her
that she had
to wait for
the Secret Service to arrive. Eventually, Michael
Casper,
who
is named as a defendant in the lawsuit, arrived. He wore a dark
suit, earpiece and lapel pin. He told Weise that she had been
“ID’d”
and that if
she had any ill intentions she would be
arrested. She
assured him that she did
not and was allowed to
proceed to her seat,
where Young was waiting.
According to
the lawsuit, Casper
consulted with other White
House event staffers who advised
him of a
White House policy
prohibiting people from attending this public event
if they
held a viewpoint other than that of the president. Casper then
ran back
to Weise and Young and forced them to leave.
After the
incident, Secret
Service confirmed to Weise and
Young that they were removed
because a
White House event
staffer noticed that Weise had a “No More Blood for
Oil”
bumper sticker on her car. Eight of the nine members of the
Colorado
congressional delegation, including Democrats and Republicans,
have since
publicly condemned what happened to Weise and
Young, and
have called for answers
from the White House.
“What was
supposed to be an
historic opportunity for us to
attend an event with a sitting
president
quickly turned into a
humiliating and frightening experience,” Weise
said. “We had
every right to attend the president’s event, and have
decided to
fight back to protect the Constitutional rights of all
Americans.”
In
addition
to Casper, today’s lawsuit names Denver
resident Jay Bob
Klinkerman as a
defendant, as well as five
unidentified White House
event staffers. Attorneys
said that
when they uncover the identities of
those as-yet-unknown officials,
they will be named in the
lawsuit.
“We
believe
that our clients were expelled from this public
meeting on the
basis of a policy
formulated in Washington and
implemented throughout
the country,” said Mark
Silverstein,
Legal Director of the ACLU of
Colorado. “This case is not just
about two people, it is about
protecting the rights and
liberties of every
single
American.”
The
ACLU said
that similar incidents have occurred at
presidential visits
across the country.
According to news
reports, individuals considered
to have critical viewpoints
were removed or excluded from Social
Security town hall
meetings in Arizona,
North Dakota and New Hampshire.
Today’s
lawsuit was filed in
U.S. District Court for the
District of Colorado. In
addition to Hansen
and Silverstein,
attorneys in the case are Catherine Crump of
the
national ACLU
and Martha Tierney and Jerremy Ramp of Denver-based law firm
Kelly
Haglund Garnsey & Kahn, who are acting as ACLU of Colorado
cooperating
attorneys.
Weise and Young have created a Web site with
background
information on the incident at: www.denverthree.org.
For a copy of the lawsuit go to: www.aclu.org/freespeech/gen/21687lgl20051121.html
Additional statements by Weise and Young are
available at: www.freespeech/gen/21704res20051121.html.
|