American Civil Liberties Union

The LGBT Project fights discrimination and moves public opinion on LGBT rights through the courts, legislatures and public education. >> More About the Project


Meet 10 Couples Contact Us

Freedom Files - Season 2
Ideological Exclusion

ACLU NewsfeedsACLU News Feed
ACLU Blog
ACLU Podcasts

Hispanic AIDS Forum v. Bruno Case Profile
03/17/2005

Transgender discrimination. Status: awaiting trial.

The ACLU brought the lawsuit on behalf of the Hispanic AIDS Forum (HAF) in 2001 after the agency was forced out of its home of 10 years in New York City because the landlord yielded to complaints from another tenant that the agency's transgender clients were using the "wrong" restrooms.

HAF repeatedly tried to negotiate with the landlord to reach an agreement over the use of the restrooms that would be acceptable to all parties, but the landlord refused to renew the lease, saying it didn't even want the transgender clients in any of the common areas of the building.

Although the landlord claims that transgender people are not protected by the state's civil rights laws, the ACLU points out in its brief that trial courts in four previous cases have all held that discrimination against transgender people is illegal in New York. HAF's TransLatina service program is in a Queens neighborhood that is an epicenter of the AIDS epidemic in U.S. Latino communities.

News
> ACLU Urges Appeals Court to Uphold Gender Identity Protections in New York (5/19/2004)
> ACLU Asks Appeals Court to Reject Attempt to End Gender Identity Protections in New York State (4/21/2004)
> Judge Allows Transgender Discrimination Claims to Go Forward in Lawsuit Over Illegal Eviction of Latino AIDS Agency (10/15/2003)
> ACLU Challenges Queens Landlord's Claim That Transgender People Are Not Entitled to Use Bathrooms or Common Areas of Building (6/26/2003)
> Judge's Rulings Favor Latino AIDS Agency in Transgender Discrimination Suit (1/16/2003)
> Latino AIDS Agency Evicted Because Transgender Clients Used 'Wrong' Bathroom, ACLU Charges in NY Lawsuit (6/26/2001)


Legal Documents
> HAF v. Bruno - ACLU Motion on Protective Order (3/16/2005)
> HAF v. Bruno - Judge's Decision on protective order motion (3/16/2005)
> HAF v. Bruno Appeal - ACLU Brief (3/16/2005)
> HAF v. Bruno Appeal - Defendant's Brief (3/16/2005)
> HAF v. Bruno complaint (3/16/2005)
> HAF v. Bruno Trial Court Decision (3/16/2005)
> Opposition to Motion to Dismiss in HAF v. Bruno, et al (6/26/2003)


Additional Resources
> HAF Background on AIDS in Latina/o Transgender community (3/16/2005)
> TransLatinas - HAF & Liz Profile (3/15/2005)
> Why We're Asking Courts and Legislatures for Transgender Equality (1/1/2003)

Click to show/hide issues list
Your Local ACLUcongressional scorecardmultimediaforumspublicationssupport usstorecontact